Tuesday, October 8, 2013

DIY Sharpie Mug - Does It Really Work?

So, I'm sure you've seen the Sharpie mugs all over Pinterest in the last couple of months.  They claim, "all you need is a marker, a dollar store mug, and an oven," but...the results seem to be varied.  Some say it worked awesome, others say it was a total fail.  So which is it?  Is it worth the effort to attempt this project, or will it be a total waste of time? 


I'm here to say that yes, it does work, BUT....maybe not quite as simplified as some claim.  
Here's how it worked for me.

I attempted this project months ago with just plain ol' Sharpie permanent markers and a couple of Corelle mugs I got at the thrift store.  I spent quite a while making a design, then I baked it just like the blog post told me to, and.....it was a complete failure.  It washed right off with just a hand washing in the sink. 

 So I did more research and found that in all reality oil based paint markers are really what you need.  These are a bit expensive, I think they were about $3.47 each at Hobby Lobby.  I used 40% off coupons so it wasn't SO bad, plus I figure these should last quite awhile and I can get plenty of uses out of them so they were worth it to me.  (You can find these in the artist's paint section at any big craft store.)


I also read that wiping down the entire mug with alcohol wipes is also a good idea to remove any grease or oils from your fingers that may be on it that would cause the ink/paint to not soak in to the glaze.

(source)

A few weeks after my first failed attempt I came across this image/post for BFF mugs, and it was my inspiration to try it again.  At the time, we were living in Ohio and were in the middle of preparing to move cross country back to Florida.  I was leaving a BFF behind, so this seemed like the perfect project to try out.  Fast forward many months to when I finally got around to actually doing this, and that'll bring you to today's post.  : )

  I started with a plain white mug from Walmart, it was a Better Homes and Gardens brand.  Something to remember about these is that, the cheaper the mug the better this project works.  The better quality the mug the better the glaze will be on it and it'll be more resistant to absorbing the paint/marker.  My dollar store didn't have any plain white mugs at the time so that's why I got one from Wally World.

The inspiration post said to practice drawing the states by hand and then use an eyeliner pencil to draw the outline on the mug, then do your marker/paint over that.  I wasn't confident in my state-drawing skills, so I went another route.


1.) I printed out an outline of each state and got it sized to fit the mug.
2.)  I shaded the back of each image with pencil lead.
3.)  I taped them to the mug and traced the outline with pencil.  Because of the pencil shading on the back of the image, it left the outline on the mug.
4.)  I traced over the outline with my paint marker, and drew a little heart where I had placed my dots.


I then let it dry a few minutes before I did my next step.


At this point I used the eyeliner trick to map out a pattern for my dash marks.


Then I went over the eyeliner with the paint marker, and once it was dry I wiped away any visible eyeliner marks. 


Here it is all painted and ready to go in the oven.  Now....let me share a bit of advice here.  As soon as my paint was dry, like 10 minutes later, I put it in the oven, but that wasn't the best idea.  Any areas where the paint had been a little thick ended up chipping off even after the baking process.  I had to fix them and re-bake it.


I should have, and what I would recommend for you, would be to let it dry for 24 hours before baking.


A lot of the posts that you see about these mugs say to bake it for 30 minutes at 350, but I recommend 425.  At 350 the glaze just doesn't get hot enough to absorb the ink/paint, so I did mine at 425.

I put it in while the oven was cold.  This allows the mug to heat up along with the oven so that it won't crack.  Start your 30 minutes once the oven reaches 425.  Also, once the 30 minutes are up, turn the oven off but leave the mug inside until the oven is cold.  Again, this is so the mug won't crack with any abrupt temperature changes.


One more thing I can tell you from experience is the colors can change on you.  The little hearts started out being a bright red, but after baking they had turned into a dark eggplant shade of purple as you can see above.  So just keep that possibility in mind if you decide to attempt a design that needs to have specific colors.


Once I fixed the chipping paint after the first bake and baked it a second time, I tested it out.  I washed it in a sink of hot soapy water just like I would any other dish.  It held up well.  I lightly scraped my fingernail all over it, it held up well.   I don't have a dishwasher so I can't tell you if it would hold up to that or not, but a regular hand washing was just fine.  

* Update - a couple of readers have come back and commented that theirs held up well in the dishwasher.  However, just to be on the safe side (and for the sake of the longevity of your mug) I would recommend sticking with a gentle hand washing. *

I filled it with some tea bags and sent it off to my friend.  It made her day!  : )
She did the last test phase for me, one that I forgot...testing whether the paint in the bottom of the cup held up against hot liquids.  She said she had Hospice on speed dial just in case she ended up drinking the "miss you" and suffered from paint toxification.  But not to worry, it held up just fine and medical personnel were not needed.

So...all in all I would call this project a success and now I know some tips for making things easier next time around.  

Have you tried this little project yet?  Was it a success or fail?  Any other tips you'd like to share to help others out?  Be sure to come back and let me know if this has inspired you to try one out and how it worked for you!



      
(Affiliate Links)



Linking up over at:

82 comments:

  1. Must day I check your blog often and was thrilled to see a new post! Thanks for sharing this with us! I aleays see these linked parties on different blogs...that would be a good linked party "Pintrest Fails & How to make em work" :)

    Happy Fall,
    Sherri Smith

    ReplyDelete
  2. I love my adorable new mug! Your tutorial makes this seem easy and fun to do. The possibilities are endless.

    ReplyDelete
  3. What a wonderful idea. All of my bestest girlfriends live far away from me. I think this is a great gift idea. Thanks, Stephanie!

    ReplyDelete
  4. GREAT idea!!! I have a Grandson in Florida, so I think I will make one of these for him!!!
    Thank you!
    Hope things are going well for all of you!
    Blessings,
    J

    ReplyDelete
  5. That's really great! Thanks for the information.

    ReplyDelete
  6. Hi Stephanie, these are adorable. I think they look great.
    Jeannie

    ReplyDelete
  7. Have you had any feedback from someone who is able to run it through a dishwasher? I'm curious :) Great project! I'm looking forward to doing my own!

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. No, no feedback yet on how they hold up with dishwashers. I'm curious to know as well.

      Delete
    2. I've made one set and put them through the dishwasher on the normal cycle. They turned out great! I'm getting ready to make another set now.

      Delete
    3. I followed the instructions, oil-based, 425* etc... It held up through the dishwasher for ONE cycle. I got confident and washed it again... A little chipped off... Again... A little more... Needless to say, they are not dishwasher safe. But, still a great and cute craft. Just warn giftees to hand-wash.

      Delete
    4. Thank you so much for giving us feedback on the dishwasher, it's good to know!

      Delete
  8. Thank you! I'm going to go make a sharpie mug now...

    ReplyDelete
  9. Thanks for this post: all the pics and detailed instructions are VERY helpful!

    ReplyDelete
  10. I am going to make these this weekend and was wondering does it make a difference if you use a stoneware or porcelain mug?

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. I'm not really sure about the stoneware vs. porcelain mugs. All I know is that the cheaper the mug the better this project works. The better quality the mug the better the glaze will be on it and it'll be more resistant to absorbing the paint/marker. Good luck! Let me know how it turns out if you decide to try a stoneware mug.

      Delete
    2. My mug says it's not microwavable safe will it be ok if I put it in the oven before it heats up and let it cool down with the oven as well?

      Delete
    3. I'm not 100% positive about this, but I would think that it would be ok. Generally when something says it's not microwave safe it means that after heating it in the microwave it will be really hot to the touch, versus dishes that ARE microwave safe that stay cooler to the touch even after heating. But I would think that if it slowly heats up with the oven, and then slowly cools down that would be ok. If you try it out, come back and let us know how it worked for you.

      Delete
  11. I have bought stoneware coloured mugs to try this on... will let you guys know if it works

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. I tried it on stoneware mugs and worked just fine. :)

      Delete
  12. When you bake it, do you start the 30 mins once it gets to 425, or right when you put it in the oven?

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. I just did this and counted the 30 minutes from when it hit 425. Worked perfectly.

      Delete
    2. I agree, count from when it hits 425. Put it in a cold oven, set your temp, then start your timer once it gets preheated to 425. After the 30 minutes turn the oven off then leave it in there until it's cold again.

      Delete
  13. Hello, I have been peaking around your blog and just love it.
    I love these mug ideas. I just recently made one of my own and it turned out perfect.

    ReplyDelete
  14. hi! this was extremely helpful! i just wanted to let you know, the link that you say has tips and tricks no longer works. i keep getting an expired page! but thanks!

    ReplyDelete
  15. Hello! My name is Emma & I'm currently working on a Valentines Day Round-up for my blog Vildmarket.com. This is a great tutorial for these mugs & I was going to feature it on my round-up. Just let me know if you would rather I did not & I will take it down.

    Thank you in advance,
    *Emma

    ReplyDelete
  16. Hi! Thanks for the lovely tutorial :) Just wondering if I should bake the mugs individually or would baking them together be ok?

    Thanks!

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. I haven't tried it, but I would think that baking them together would be just fine.

      Delete
  17. Replies
    1. VERY carefully, lol! I held the very end of the marker with the paint end down in the cup, and very carefully wrote out the words and hoped and prayed I had done it right because I couldn't really see what I was doing. I messed it up the first time, but I just wiped it off with some alcohol, let it dry, and tried it again. I got it right the 2nd time.

      Delete
  18. do you how much does it last? ;/ i guess its not for EVER..

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. I have no idea how long they last. I would imagine they'll last close to forever if you're careful about hand washing them and not putting them in the dishwasher, but I really couldn't say for sure.

      Delete
  19. Whats the eyeliner trick? And are you positive it doesn't work with normal sharpie markers??

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. The eyeliner trick is that you use an eyeliner pencil to draw out your image, then you trace over it with the marker/paint. Once the paint is dry you can just wipe away any eyeliner marks that are still visible. You'll want to do that before you bake it so there's no chance of them becoming permanent.

      I can't say 100% that regular markers don't work, I only know that when I tried them they didn't work, and washed right off. I only baked them at 350 though, and never did try the higher temperature of 425. Who knows, maybe the higher temps would have worked. If you try it and it works be sure to come back and let us know!

      Delete
  20. I hand washed mine after only doing one coat of marker and baking only once and some of the black rubbed off a bit. Now that I have just read your blog, I'm going to try doing a second and third coat of marker and baking a second time. Thank you for posting this!

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. You're welcome! I hope it worked out for you the 2nd time around.

      Delete
  21. Good post for sharing and it brings innovative and unique ideas and thoughts to do this kind of creativity and these mugs looks great and i appreciate all the endeavors done behind that. Good work Guys!!

    ReplyDelete
  22. I {really} LOVE this! I'm hosting a Sharpie crafts link party on my blog this week, and I'd love it if you wanted to link up! Favorites will be featured in a compilation post next week, & we're giving away a $50 Target GC and Sharpie prize pack! http://bit.ly/1c0IEvS

    ReplyDelete
  23. Thank you so much for this post!!! I tried this so many times - had great ideas from my kids - only to have it all wash off. I took your advice, bought the oil-based Sharpies, etc and it worked! I'm going to use this as a school auction idea - thanks again!!

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. I'm so glad it finally worked for you and that I could be of help! Thanks so much for letting me know.

      Delete
  24. Hi! Thanks for the tip on the Sharpies! I tried a heart on the bottom of the mug just to test a bit and got the same result with the red, it turned a magenta-ish pink-purple. Are the photos at the bottom of your post the final product AFTER baking or before? And if they are the after, how did you fix the problem with the color changing? Any information you could provide would be helpful!

    Thanks again!

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. The photos at the bottom with the bright red heart were actually taken before I baked it. The eggplant purple color is what it changed to after baking. So yes, be very aware that colors do change during baking, except for black.

      Delete
  25. It seems to work so well! Thanks for the awesome review and that is such a gorgeous mug!

    ReplyDelete
  26. Found your site (a happy find!) while searching for the nitty griiy on the DYI Sharpie mugs. We want to use this idea as a simple craft takeaway at an upcoming Ladies Tea hosted by the women's ministry group at church. Thank you for all your great suggestions. We will have ladies from 5-105 & this seems doable for all...even me who doesn't posses a crafty bone in my body!

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Oh that sounds like a such a FUN idea for a ladies gathering! And you're right, it's the perfect solution for ladies of all ages. I hope it turned out wonderfully for you.

      Delete
  27. My oven gets a bit smoky and an odd smell during the baking step, is this normal, or just my oven? Thanks!

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Mine did get just a little bit stinky during the baking process, but not smoky. I would say that's probably not normal.

      Delete
  28. Good product and best tool for marketing and advertisement with a logo attached on the mug.

    Promo Logo Mugs

    ReplyDelete
  29. Do you have a recommendation for the best site to find outlines of states. I am going to try Maryland and it doesn't look very easy! Luckily the state my friend is moving to is PA, so I lucked out on that state. :)

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. I just use Google images and type in, "Outline of Maryland" or whatever the state may be, then just take your pick from whatever images it brings up. Some will be more detailed than others, but there should be a couple that are a bit more simplified.

      Delete
  30. Hey!
    I hope that you see this I know it's from a while ago!
    I used your method (thankyou for explaining SO throughly!) and it worked perfectly, I left the black for over 24 hours to set before I cooked it in the oven like you said and that was a few days ago, I tried washing I etc and it was great but today before I went to post it I realised that some of the black had scratched off a little bit, I checked it in other areas by scratching it and it wasn't coming off but a couple if other bits that I tried scratched of too (just tiny!) I touched them up with the pen again but I had to post it (it needs to get to Australia within the next week) I couldn't leave it and cook it again :(. When my boyfriend receives it if I tell him to put it in the oven again do you think it will damage the rest of it? Or will it just set the bits that I touched up? It looks so perfect but I don't want him to not be able to use it bevause he's worried it will scratch off :') xxx

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. I don't THINK it will ruin it if he bakes it again. It should just set up the paint that you added to it. Another thing he could try that I've read about since I posted this is, after it's baked spray a coat or two of a clear acrylic sealer over the design for added protection. I would cover/tape off the rim so that the sealer doesn't get on the part that goes in your mouth and then spray just the design with two coats of sealer. I haven't tried this method, but in theory it seems like it would work pretty well. Hope that helps!

      Delete
  31. Hi! I was really glad to see the mention of stoneware vs. ceramic or porcelain in this blog. I have purchased like 14 stoneware mugs from the dollar tree and have attempted this project with regular sharpies, oil based sharpies and painters pens. I have used the baking techniques of letting the paint dry for 24 hours and then baking at 350 for 30 minutes and the other technique of baking at 425 for 30 minutes after letting it preheat with the oven and then letting it cool down with the oven for several hours. with both techniques I let them sit 24 hours after baking before washing. the sharpie didn't last and after a good soak and applying pressure, the design came off. the oil based sharpies faired even worse. the design smudged off on my hand when I picked it up to wash it. The painters pen did the best but parts of the wording came off after soaking in water for a little bit. it was however difficult to scrub the rest of the design off so the mug was clean. I have considered using ceramic or porcelain mugs instead (even though stoneware is a type of ceramic) or using a spray on type of sealant. Any suggestions or tips would be appreciated because I really would like this to work because it's such a cute idea for Christmas presents and I have a lot of people to buy for......and I have no room for these 14 mugs. Haha. :)

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. I too would love to know how to seal it.
      I used the painters markers, on a simple mug from Walmart..... Ceramic I suppose....
      I need to ship this over to my boyfriend ASAP so I pray it worked! I afraid to test it out

      Delete
    2. I'm not really sure what to tell you, I don't know why it's not working for you. I made another one this week as a gift using a Corelle mug I got a thrift store and it worked just fine. My only suggestion would be to try something other than stoneware. Also, I have read that using a spray sealant helps. I would tape off the rim of the mug so that it doesn't get on the part where your mouth will go, but then give it 2 light coats of a clear acrylic sealer and see if that helps.

      Delete
  32. Hey there!
    I used PAINTERS Opaque Paint Markers. It says they're good for plates so I figured mugs would work as well. They can be used on fabrics, wood, paper, terra cotta, glass, ceramic, plastic etc....
    So today was the day that I baked my mug, after letting it sit for 24hrs.

    Now I'm nervous.... How do I test it without ruining everything if it didnt work??

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Test it VERY carefully, lol! I usually just barely touch the edge of whatever design I've done to see if it smudges. If not, then I give it a light scratch with my fingernail, again just on the edge though. If that seems good then I lightly test it all over by touching it and then scratching it. If it seems ok then I cross my fingers, hold my breath, and hope for the best as I give it a hand washing.

      Delete
    2. I realize this is an old post, but I just bought the same markers for the same project. Did it work for you? Are they machine washable? Thanks for any information you can offer.

      Delete
  33. I'm thinking about doing this project with some teens at the library where I work, but I'm worried about putting the paint marker on the inside of the mug. I've heard that while it may not come off completely, there still is some risk of poisoning from the paint markers. Do you know anything about this?

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Don't hold me to it because I'm sure there's always a bit of risk if you paint something on the inside, but that being said, the friend I made this cup for is still alive and kickin' a year later. :) But if you're not comfortable with doing that then just skip that part. It's a little bit difficult to paint down inside them anyways.

      Delete
  34. Hi! I love this idea, and tried it on a colored mug with black and white oil based sharpies. I'd done the craft before with 30 minutes at 350, but this time I did 30 minutes at 425. I don't know if you've tried it with white paint yet, but I wanted to let you know that my white paint burnt and came out brown. I went over it and re-baked it at 350. Perhaps 425 is the optimal temperature, but I would be cautious with lighter colored paints, because they will likely burn and come out brown. :(

    When using whites or lighter colors, as long as you let it air dry for 24-48 hours before baking, I think it should be ok with handwashing. Just wanted to let you know!

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Thank you for sharing your experience! I just recently made one where I used white paint over top of the black paint (white polka dots on black letters) and the white turned gray. It still turned out cute even though they were gray and I was fine with it. I'm sorry yours turned brown though. :(

      Delete
  35. Hi! Last year I tried the ole' "just draw on the mug with a sharpie" method and it DID NOT work. I worked long and hard for a mug for my best friend only to have it come off when she hand-washed it :( I am really happy I found your site but I have a quick question.

    How has the inside of your cup lasted? and also would you say it is safe to drink out of?
    THANKS

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. With daily use and therefore daily washings the design did start to wear off after several months of use. My friend that I gave this cup to is still alive and kickin' and the paint wearing off didn't harm her, but if you're very picky about what goes into your body then I would recommend leaving out the design in the bottom of the cup.

      Delete
  36. Great tutorial!! I just painted my mugs and am in the drying process. I used mainly gold, with just a little black and red. Any experience with the metallic paint pens? Also, the product insert with my mugs says "oven safe up to 250*" -- Do you know if your mugs said anything about the temperature? Do you think they'll be OK up to 450? I am so afraid they will crack!

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Hopefully your mug was fine in the hot oven and didn't crack. I've tried a couple of different kinds of mugs and never had a problem, but I guess there are no guarantees. How did the metallic paint turn out? I haven't used metallic yet.

      Delete
  37. I tried these last night and they worked like a charm. Beware of the smell though. I would suggest opening windows in your house cause it can be quite overwhelming. Also, the colors change..

    Red turns into purple
    Blue turns into green
    Gold turns into silver
    Yellow turns into a light brown

    I will keep experimenting with the colors once my mugs are back in stock

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Thank you for letting us know how the colors change! I knew that red turns purple and white turns grey, but I didn't know how the other colors changed. I haven't tried it for myself yet, but I've read that the Bic brand stays true to color and doesn't change with baking.

      Delete
  38. Hello! Do you put your mugs on a baking sheet to cook?

    ReplyDelete
  39. Hi, so glad I came across this BEFORE I tried it with a regular sharpie. I went out and bought the fancy ones (craftsmart brand, which they assured me are the same as sharpie or money back)...
    I want to make some as Christmas gifts but deff want to make a practice mug first. Question: has anyone tried white paint on black mug yet? That's what I have at home (and the markers I bought are a multi-color set) and I'm thinking that I wasn't to write a favorite book quote but wanted to check in before I start haha. Thanks for the tips so far :-)

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. In my experience the white turns gray, but that was with the Sharpie brand and it was white paint over top of black paint. So I can't say for sure how white paint would react on a black mug. Come back and let us know how it turned out if you try it!

      Delete
  40. Hey,

    I baked mine yesterday and had some fading and chipping. When you baked yours a second time to fix it, did you just draw over your old design and fill in the spots? Thanks!!

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Yes, I just drew over the design and filled in where needed.

      Delete
  41. Are the fumes from the baking harmful?

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Not entirely sure, but I'm still alive so it can't be too bad.

      Delete
  42. Can you use a microwave instead of an oven?

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. No, I would not recommend using a microwave for this project. I just don't think a microwave could get the mug hot enough to absorb the ink.

      Delete
  43. Runing out of time to do these. Really want to make them. So many suggestions. Please do these really work. Hate to give them and they rub of in a month. Xmas gifts for my sons corp of cadets members at college. Please honestly will oil based sharpie, baking and coating with sealant last even just getting them out of oven much less dishwashing.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. The design will last for a few months with daily hand washing. It may fade quicker when using a dishwasher, but it also may last longer if not used daily and if always hand washed only. If you want something more permanent you might want to check into paint markers that are made specifically for ceramics.

      Delete

Thanks for stopping by and taking the time to comment. I love hearing from you!

Related Posts Plugin for WordPress, Blogger...